Home

WorldCat Home About WorldCat Help

Search

Search for Library Items Search for Lists Search for Contacts Search for a Library

Create lists, bibliographies and reviews: or

Cite/Export

Cite/Export

Copy a citation

APA (6th ed.)

Chicago (Author-Date, 15th ed.)

Harvard (18th ed.)

MLA (7th ed.)

Turabian (6th ed.)

Export a citation
Export to RefWorks Export to EndNote / Reference Manager Export to EasyBib
Export to EndNote / Reference Manager(non-Latin) Cancel
Note: Citations are based on reference standards. However, formatting rules can vary widely between applications and fields of interest or study. The specific requirements or preferences of your reviewing publisher, classroom teacher, institution or organization should be applied.
Print
E-mail

E-mail

All fields are required.

The E-mail Address(es) field is required. Please enter recipient e-mail address(es).

The E-mail Address(es) you entered is(are) not in a valid format. Please re-enter recipient e-mail address(es).

You may send this item to up to five recipients.
Enter recipient e-mail address(es): Separate up to five addresses with commas (,)
The name field is required. Please enter your name.
Enter your name: Subject:
The E-mail message field is required. Please enter the message.
E-mail Message: I thought you might be interested in this item at http://www.worldcat.org/oclc/642352156 Title: Science and religion : are they compatible? Author: D C Dennett; Alvin Plantinga Publisher: New York : Oxford University Press, 2011. ISBN/ISSN: 9780199738427 0199738424 OCLC:642352156

Please verify that you are not a robot.

Cancel
Share
Permalink

Permalink

Copy this URL to link to this page:

Write a review
Rate this item:
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5

Science and religion : are they compatible?

Preview this item

Checking...

Science and religion : are they compatible?

Author:	D C Dennett; Alvin Plantinga
Publisher:	New York : Oxford University Press, 2011.
Series:	Point/counterpoint series (Oxford, England)
Edition/Format:	Print book : EnglishView all editions and formats
Summary:	"One of today's most controversial and heated issues is whether or not the conflict between science and religion can be reconciled. In Science and Religion: Are They Compatible?, renowned philosophers Daniel C. Dennett and Alvin Plantinga expand upon the arguments that they presented in an exciting live debate held at the 2009 American Philosophical Association Central Division conference.
Rating:	based on 1 rating(s) 1 with a review
Subjects	Religion and science. Religion Naturwissenschaften View all subjects
More like this	User tags User lists Similar Items

Find a copy in the library

Finding libraries that hold this item...

Details

Additional Physical Format:	Online version: Dennett, Daniel Clement. Science and religion. New York : Oxford University Press, 2011 (OCoLC)764526232
Document Type:	Book
All Authors / Contributors:	D C Dennett; Alvin Plantinga Find more information about:
ISBN:	9780199738427 0199738424
OCLC Number:	642352156
Description:	viii, 82 pages ; 21 cm.
Contents:	Science and religion: where the conflict really lies / Alvin Plantinga -- Truths that miss their mark: naturalism unscathed / Daniel C. Dennett -- Superman vs. God? / Alvin Plantinga -- Habits of imagination and their effect on incredulity : reply to Plantinga (essay 2) / Daniel C. Dennett -- Naturalism against science / Alvin Plantinga -- No miracles needed / Daniel C. Dennett.
Series Title:	Point/counterpoint series (Oxford, England)
Responsibility:	Daniel C. Dennett, Alvin Plantinga.

Abstract:

An enlightening discussion that will motivate students to think critically, the book opens with Plantinga's assertion that Christianity is compatible with evolutionary theory because Christians Read more...

Reviews

Editorial reviews

Publisher Synopsis

an interesting exchange on a very timely topic, and one which gives readers a good illustration of how this debate is often conducted today, especially from the atheistic side. * Brendan Sweetman, Read more...

User-contributed reviews

WorldCat User Reviews (1)

Science and religion: are they compatible?

by wppalmer (WorldCat user published 2015-04-15) Very Good

Permalink

Review of Science and religion: are they compatible? by Daniel C, Dennett, D. C. & Alvin Plantinga.

CITATION: Dennett, D. C. & Plantinga, A.(2011). Science and religion: are they compatible? (Point/Counterpoint series). New York: Oxford University Press.

Comments: Dr W. P. Palmer.

The book is just 82 page long and is a debate between two well-known scholars (philosophers) on whether science and religion are compatible. The arguments are those which were presented in a debate at the 2009 American Philosophical Association Central Division Conference. In the debate, Alvin Plantinga makes the case that science and religion are compatible whilst Daniel C. Dennett, as an atheist, puts the case for incompatibility. However the argument soon shifts with both Plantinga and Dennett accepting that science and religion are compatible, but with Dennett considering the probability of compatibility to be very low.

The starting arguments relate to evolution. Most readers want an answer to the question ‘Does holding a standard scientific view of evolution (if there is one) logically conflict with holding a religious (Christian) belief?’ Plantinga does make the point that he considers that there are three main evolutionary arguments against religion (page 7). These are (i) that the concept of evolution can replace the concept of a designer (ii) that evolution is a process that is so wasteful and cruel that it is not one that a loving God would use and (iii) that the concept of unguided evolution is more probable than guided evolution as unguided evolution is a simpler explanation (Ockham’s Razor). Having stated the evolutionary arguments against religion, Plantinga then goes on to counter each of these arguments in turn. Different readers will evaluate the validity of the counter-arguments differently. My own view that he did not present a good enough case opposing the second evolutionary argument against religion. He does, however, make the good general point that academic argument is unlikely to convince anyone of the truth of religion.

Dennett then had his turn to argue against the existence of God. He gives away what might have been expected to be a strong line of defence and agrees that ‘contemporary evolutionary theory is compatible with theistic belief’ (p. 26), but then chips away at the argument by exploring definitions. Dennett uses less space in the book than Plantinga. Each of them has a second chance to improve on their arguments with a final chapter each, but in the end, unsurprisingly neither argument defeats the other. After reading this book, Christians will remain Christians and atheists will remain atheists. I was not convinced that either side deployed the most cogent arguments to support their case.

BILL PALMER

Was this review helpful to you?

Linked Data

Primary Entity

<http://www.worldcat.org/oclc/642352156> # Science and religion : are they compatible?
    a schema:CreativeWork, schema:Book ;
    library:oclcnum "642352156" ;
    library:placeOfPublication <http://dbpedia.org/resource/New_York_City> ; # New York
    library:placeOfPublication <http://id.loc.gov/vocabulary/countries/nyu> ;
    schema:about <http://id.worldcat.org/fast/1093848> ; # Religion and science
    schema:about <http://experiment.worldcat.org/entity/work/data/913162749#Topic/vallas_es_tudomany_parbeszed> ; # vallás és tudomány--párbeszéd
    schema:about <http://id.loc.gov/authorities/classification/BL240> ;
    schema:about <http://dewey.info/class/201.65/e22/> ;
    schema:about <http://experiment.worldcat.org/entity/work/data/913162749#Topic/naturwissenschaften> ; # Naturwissenschaften
    schema:about <http://experiment.worldcat.org/entity/work/data/913162749#Topic/religion> ; # Religion
    schema:bookFormat bgn:PrintBook ;
    schema:contributor <http://viaf.org/viaf/79040329> ; # Alvin Plantinga
    schema:creator <http://viaf.org/viaf/99825560> ; # Daniel Clement Dennett
    schema:datePublished "2011" ;
    schema:description "An enlightening discussion that will motivate students to think critically, Science and Religion: Are They Compatible? opens with Plantinga's assertion that Christianity is compatible with evolutionary theory because Christians believe that God created the living world, and it is entirely possible that God did so by using a process of evolution. Dennett vigorously rejects this argument, provoking a reply from Plantinga, another response from Dennett, and final statements from both sides. As philosophers, the authors possess expert skills in critical analysis; their arguments provide a model of dialogue between those who strongly disagree. Ideal for courses in philosophy of religion, science and religion, and philosophy of science, Science and Religion is also captivating reading for general readers."--Pub. desc."@en ;
    schema:description ""One of today's most controversial and heated issues is whether or not the conflict between science and religion can be reconciled. In Science and Religion: Are They Compatible?, renowned philosophers Daniel C. Dennett and Alvin Plantinga expand upon the arguments that they presented in an exciting live debate held at the 2009 American Philosophical Association Central Division conference."@en ;
    schema:description "Science and religion: where the conflict really lies / Alvin Plantinga -- Truths that miss their mark: naturalism unscathed / Daniel C. Dennett -- Superman vs. God? / Alvin Plantinga -- Habits of imagination and their effect on incredulity : reply to Plantinga (essay 2) / Daniel C. Dennett -- Naturalism against science / Alvin Plantinga -- No miracles needed / Daniel C. Dennett."@en ;
    schema:exampleOfWork <http://worldcat.org/entity/work/id/913162749> ;
    schema:inLanguage "en" ;
    schema:isPartOf <http://experiment.worldcat.org/entity/work/data/913162749#Series/point_counterpoint_series> ; # Point/counterpoint series
    schema:isPartOf <http://experiment.worldcat.org/entity/work/data/913162749#Series/point_counterpoint_series_oxford_england> ; # Point/counterpoint series (Oxford, England)
    schema:isSimilarTo <http://www.worldcat.org/oclc/764526232> ;
    schema:name "Science and religion : are they compatible?"@en ;
    schema:productID "642352156" ;
    schema:publication <http://www.worldcat.org/title/-/oclc/642352156#PublicationEvent/new_york_oxford_university_press_2011> ;
    schema:publisher <http://experiment.worldcat.org/entity/work/data/913162749#Agent/oxford_university_press> ; # Oxford University Press
    schema:workExample <http://worldcat.org/isbn/9780199738427> ;
    umbel:isLike <http://bnb.data.bl.uk/id/resource/GBB1A6983> ;
    wdrs:describedby <http://www.worldcat.org/title/-/oclc/642352156> ;
    .

Related Entities

<http://dbpedia.org/resource/New_York_City> # New York
    a schema:Place ;
    schema:name "New York" ;
    .

<http://dewey.info/class/201.65/e22/>
a schema:Intangible ;
.

<http://experiment.worldcat.org/entity/work/data/913162749#Agent/oxford_university_press> # Oxford University Press
    a bgn:Agent ;
    schema:name "Oxford University Press" ;
    .

<http://experiment.worldcat.org/entity/work/data/913162749#Series/point_counterpoint_series> # Point/counterpoint series
    a bgn:PublicationSeries ;
    schema:hasPart <http://www.worldcat.org/oclc/642352156> ; # Science and religion : are they compatible?
    schema:name "Point/counterpoint series" ;
    .

<http://experiment.worldcat.org/entity/work/data/913162749#Series/point_counterpoint_series_oxford_england> # Point/counterpoint series (Oxford, England)
    a bgn:PublicationSeries ;
    schema:hasPart <http://www.worldcat.org/oclc/642352156> ; # Science and religion : are they compatible?
    schema:name "Point/counterpoint series (Oxford, England)" ;
    .

<http://experiment.worldcat.org/entity/work/data/913162749#Topic/naturwissenschaften> # Naturwissenschaften
    a schema:Intangible ;
    schema:name "Naturwissenschaften"@en ;
    .

<http://experiment.worldcat.org/entity/work/data/913162749#Topic/religion> # Religion
    a schema:Intangible ;
    schema:name "Religion"@en ;
    .

<http://experiment.worldcat.org/entity/work/data/913162749#Topic/vallas_es_tudomany_parbeszed> # vallás és tudomány--párbeszéd
    a schema:Intangible ;
    schema:name "vallás és tudomány--párbeszéd"@en ;
    .

<http://id.loc.gov/authorities/classification/BL240>
a schema:Intangible ;
.

<http://id.loc.gov/vocabulary/countries/nyu>
    a schema:Place ;
    dcterms:identifier "nyu" ;
    .

<http://id.worldcat.org/fast/1093848> # Religion and science
    a schema:Intangible ;
    schema:name "Religion and science"@en ;
    .

<http://viaf.org/viaf/79040329> # Alvin Plantinga
    a schema:Person ;
    schema:familyName "Plantinga" ;
    schema:givenName "Alvin" ;
    schema:name "Alvin Plantinga" ;
    .

<http://viaf.org/viaf/99825560> # Daniel Clement Dennett
    a schema:Person ;
    schema:familyName "Dennett" ;
    schema:givenName "Daniel Clement" ;
    schema:givenName "D. C." ;
    schema:name "Daniel Clement Dennett" ;
    .

<http://worldcat.org/isbn/9780199738427>
    a schema:ProductModel ;
    schema:isbn "0199738424" ;
    schema:isbn "9780199738427" ;
    .

<http://www.worldcat.org/oclc/764526232>
    a schema:CreativeWork ;
    rdfs:label "Science and religion." ;
    schema:description "Online version:" ;
    schema:isSimilarTo <http://www.worldcat.org/oclc/642352156> ; # Science and religion : are they compatible?
    .

<http://www.worldcat.org/title/-/oclc/642352156>
    a genont:InformationResource, genont:ContentTypeGenericResource ;
    schema:about <http://www.worldcat.org/oclc/642352156> ; # Science and religion : are they compatible?
    schema:dateModified "2019-01-16" ;
    void:inDataset <http://purl.oclc.org/dataset/WorldCat> ;
    .

<http://www.worldcat.org/title/-/oclc/642352156#PublicationEvent/new_york_oxford_university_press_2011>
    a schema:PublicationEvent ;
    schema:location <http://dbpedia.org/resource/New_York_City> ; # New York
    schema:organizer <http://experiment.worldcat.org/entity/work/data/913162749#Agent/oxford_university_press> ; # Oxford University Press
    schema:startDate "2011" ;
    .

Content-negotiable representations

Turtle (text/turtle)
JSON-LD (application/ld+json)
RDF/XML (application/rdf+xml)
N-TRIPLES (text/plain)
HTML+RDFa (text/html)

Please sign in to WorldCat

Don't have an account? You can easily create a free account.

You:	Sign In \| Register \| My WorldCat \| My Lists \| My Watchlist \| My Reviews \| My Tags \| My Saved Searches
WorldCat:	Home \| About \| Help \| Search